There is an ancient divide within the Jewish people:
Those who wish to be embraced by the nations of the world, and those who understand that we are the Ivri — the ones who stand on the other side, chosen to be different and apart from the other nations.
The Hellenists and the Maccabees.
This divide comes with a lot of anger. Those who do not want to be different and apart blame the other Jews, those who are strong and unapologetic in their Jewishness, for the hatred directed at Jews. In their heart of hearts, they hope that being less Jewish, less different, more like the other nations, will reduce the hatred and the violence directed at our people.
They are the ones who said, “I am not a Jew, I am a German of the faith of Moses.” It was their neighbors who taught them, and everyone willing to pay attention, that Jews, no matter how much they deny their “otherness,” will always be Jews first.
What are you first? This is a question Jews have had to answer throughout history: Over and over, it was their neighbors who explained through their actions, through their violence, that Jews are always Jews before anything else.
But being hated, even after trying to erase the differences that might provoke offense, is hard.
And as a result, these Jews tried to control their own destiny. They led the way in many battles for Jewish freedom, while refusing to cooperate with their Jewish brothers and sisters who believed in a different strategy for dealing with the challenges facing the Jewish people.
During the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising, ideological divisions among Jewish resistance groups got in the way of achieving their united goal. To this day, the heroism of one group is taught and commemorated while the other is all but erased.
It happened during the “Saison,” “The Hunting Season,” during the British Mandate, when Jews helped the British authorities hunt down other Jews who were fighting the British occupation.
It happened with the Altalena.
The divide expresses itself in different answers to the same questions:
Do we create Jewish safety by striving for political legitimacy and acceptance from stronger foreign powers? Or will Jewish safety come from Jews being strong and doing what is necessary, regardless of what the other nations think of us?
Which Jews get to decide the right way to manage our future?
How far will Jews go when dealing with those who disagree? Hunt them down? Or refuse to fight our brothers?
Interestingly, this divide, and these questions, remain unanswered even in modern Israel.
And we are seeing this in a stark and horrifying display following the recent elections.
Former IDF Chief of Staff Gadi Eisenkot and the political bloc he leads got the majority of the votes from the Israelis – those who can be broadly categorized as the secular Jews (those who would rather not be too Jewy), and the Arabs (who would rather Israel not be Jewish). Prime Minister Netanyahu and the political bloc he leads got the majority of votes from the Jews – the religious and the traditionalist Jews who understand themselves to be first Jewish and Israeli second.
The Israelis vs. the Jews.
The question is, what happens now?
Because history has taught us, time and again, that when Jews refuse to stand together, those who hate us are more than happy to remind us that, in their eyes, there is no difference between us.
If you appreciate my writings and would like to support my efforts, please consider a PayPal donation to help me bring Inspiration from Zion to people around the world.